Blogs > Union Tally

A Philadelphia Union blog hosted by Christopher A. Vito and Matthew De George

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Two injuries, two questions remain for Union's first starting lineup

The Philadelphia Union are four days from the start of the 2016 season. They also have, according to manager Jim Curtin, “two spots left where there are still discussions about” who starts against Dallas.

Perhaps it’s coincidence that that number equals the amount of practice absences this week – midfielders Maurice Edu and Tranquillo Barnetta. Edu (stress reaction in leg) has yet to train with the club and has been in and out of a walking boot in recent weeks. While Curtin stopped at doubtful in his assessment, it’s almost assured the midfielder won’t play.

Barnetta received an injection in his knee, which was surgically repaired during his stint in Germany, and didn’t train with the team Tuesday or Wednesday. Curtin said that the Union, “(will) monitor that and be smart.” That seems to peg Barnetta as doubtful for the opening week with no need to rush him back.

Without those two, what does a Union lineup look like? Try this one:

Bench: McCarthy, Anderson, Creavalle, Carroll, Ilsinho, Restrepo, Herbers

Curtin’s two battles are likely for the starting center back spot alongside Richie Marquez and the composition of central midfield. He’s said that Vincent Nogueira has played as a No. 6 in preseason, and with Edu’s absence open-ended, Nogueira may see significant time there. Brian Carroll could get the nod if the Union want to go defense-first with Nogueira as the No. 8 bumping Roland Alberg, but omitting Carroll would signal that the Union want to play differently, not reverting to the caution of the past.

As for defense, Anderson has made strides, but Ken Tribbett has been one of the “revelations” of preseason and is further along in familiarity and fitness. Through Tribbett, Curtin can send the message that players who train well will be selected. The same goes for Leo Fernandes, who scored twice in training Wednesday and has impressed in preseason. He’s the logical replacement for Barnetta.

There’s no question about CJ Sapong up top. Fernandes would be an option to supplant Chris Pontius or Sebastien Le Toux on a wing was he not needed centrally, or if either of those two faltered this preseason, which they haven’t. And we don’t even need to talk about goalies, for once.

One understated aspect of the positional debate is the captaincy void. Barnetta and Edu are the last two players to wear the captain’s armband, and while Curtin lauded each for their contributions behind the scenes, someone has to lead the team out in Dallas. The need for veteran presence could shift the Nogueira/Carroll discussion in the latter’s favor. Or if could fall to a new captain – Le Toux or Ray Gaddis, perhaps – to earn that honor.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,


Anonymous Anonymous said...

if play on the field is a criterion for captaincy, why not Nogueira. He was captain for his French side before he came to Philly. There are enough French speakers in the side to translate the captain's speech.

March 2, 2016 at 3:44 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

My opinion on a few things...
- I love the idea of pure possession/attack in midfield, but no way we can go into Dallas without any real coverage for the back four. Carroll isn't ideal for me in a home game against Chicago, but he's a necessity in this case.
- I like what we've seen from Rosenberry enough that I wouldn't be surprised/worried to see him start.
- Actually, I would throw Gaddis and Le Toux into your point of "reverting to the past". Let's see what these new (better) players and style can do (minus not having true-DM coverage for the back). No way Le Toux starts for me with this new roster. He's become a second half sub to run at tired legs (if winning-hustle on defense and look for counter ball overtop. losing-lead the line of constant pressure), and that's a wonderful thing.
- My lineup for this game: Blake; Rosenberry, Marquez, Tribbett, Fabinho; Carroll, Nogueira; Fernandes, Ilsinho, Pontius; Sapong. Bench: Jones, Anderson (CB), Gaddis (OB), Creavalle (DM/OB), Alberg (DM,CAM,LW,RW), Ayuk (LW,RW), Le Toux (LW,RW,ST). Tough to leave out Herbers but he only covers one position.

March 3, 2016 at 9:58 AM 
Blogger John Gibson said...

Why it is important to make problems with this. They can solve this easily i think. Recently i used dissertation writing service for managing my dissertation writing. I did not took too much time for solving my problems.

March 7, 2016 at 1:25 AM 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home